What’s Better? Collagen Injections vs. New Facial Fillers Like Juvederm

What’s Better? Collagen Injections vs. New Facial Fillers Like Juvederm

With so many options for dermal fillers available today, how do you choose which is best for your needs? Below is a comparison chart of common collagen fillers and hyaluronic acid fillers, such as Juvederm. Juvederm offers a wide array of facial fillers, such as Vollure, Volbella and Voluma that are specifically customized for different areas of the face. This customization prevents the ‘overdone’ look and provides a very natural appearance.

  • Collagen does not last as long as JUVÉDERM® and Restylane®.
  • Most collagen products require skin testing for allergic reactions, while JUVÉDERM® and Restylane® do not. There can be between a 1-3 percent chance of allergic reactions with collagen skin treatments, but it is extremely rare with hyaluronic acid fillers.
  • Collagen fillers are derived from bovine (cow) skin or human cadaver. Newer products are made from hyaluronic acid, a naturally occurring substance that helps in hydrating your skin and replenishing its natural volume.
  • For the most part, products like JUVÉDERM® and Restylane® basically do the same thing that collagen fillers offer at similar prices.

Advantages of JUVÉDERM® Filler

  • The gel is made from hyaluronic acid, a naturally occurring substance that helps in hydrating your skin and replenishing its natural volume.
  • No allergy skin tests are required for this treatment
  • JUVÉDERM® gel flows consistently and easily into the skin and provides a smooth and natural look.
  • It is better than other hyaluronic based fillers that are granular in consistency.
  • It is the first FDA-approved hyaluronic acid dermal filler that is proven to be safe and effective for persons of color.

What it Treats

Substance

Length of Effectiveness

Area it Treats

Zyderm®

Superficial lines

Bovine Collagen

2 to 3 months

Around Face

Zyplast®

Deeper wrinkles

Bovine Collagen

2 to 3 months

Around Face

CosmoDerm®

Fine lines, wrinkles, and scars

Purified Human Collagen

2 to 3 months

Throughout face on lines and wrinkles

CosmoPlast®

Fine lines, wrinkles, and scars

Purified Human Collagen

2 to 3 months

Throughout face on lines and wrinkles

Radiesse®

Deeper Wrinkles, some Acne Scarring

Calcium Hydroxylapatatite (CaHA) Particles Suspended in a Hyaluronic Acid Gel

Approx. 1 year

Throughout the facial area

Restylane®

Lines in lower face, under eyes, increase lip size

Hyaluronic Acid

Lips: 3 to 6 months, Other: 6 to 9 months

Lips, underneath the eyes, lines such as frown lines and creases

JUVÉDERM®

Moderate to Deep wrinkling

Hyaluronic Acid

Approx. 1 year

Lips, Mouth Wrinkles, Facial lines

Perlane®

Facial wrinkles, lips, lines and creases on the face

Hyaluronic Acid

9 to 12 months

Lips, fines lines around mouth and eyes, face