With so many options for dermal fillers available today, how do you choose which is best for your needs? Below is a comparison chart of common collagen fillers and hyaluronic acid fillers, such as Juvederm. Juvederm offers a wide array of facial fillers, such as Vollure, Volbella and Voluma that are specifically customized for different areas of the face. This customization prevents the ‘overdone’ look and provides a very natural appearance.
- Collagen does not last as long as JUVÉDERM® and Restylane®.
- Most collagen products require skin testing for allergic reactions, while JUVÉDERM® and Restylane® do not. There can be between a 1-3 percent chance of allergic reactions with collagen skin treatments, but it is extremely rare with hyaluronic acid fillers.
- Collagen fillers are derived from bovine (cow) skin or human cadaver. Newer products are made from hyaluronic acid, a naturally occurring substance that helps in hydrating your skin and replenishing its natural volume.
- For the most part, products like JUVÉDERM® and Restylane® basically do the same thing that collagen fillers offer at similar prices.
Advantages of JUVÉDERM® Filler
- The gel is made from hyaluronic acid, a naturally occurring substance that helps in hydrating your skin and replenishing its natural volume.
- No allergy skin tests are required for this treatment
- JUVÉDERM® gel flows consistently and easily into the skin and provides a smooth and natural look.
- It is better than other hyaluronic based fillers that are granular in consistency.
- It is the first FDA-approved hyaluronic acid dermal filler that is proven to be safe and effective for persons of color.
What it Treats |
Substance |
Length of Effectiveness |
Area it Treats |
|
Zyderm® |
Superficial lines |
Bovine Collagen |
2 to 3 months |
Around Face |
Zyplast® |
Deeper wrinkles |
Bovine Collagen |
2 to 3 months |
Around Face |
CosmoDerm® |
Fine lines, wrinkles, and scars |
Purified Human Collagen |
2 to 3 months |
Throughout face on lines and wrinkles |
CosmoPlast® |
Fine lines, wrinkles, and scars |
Purified Human Collagen |
2 to 3 months |
Throughout face on lines and wrinkles |
Radiesse® |
Deeper Wrinkles, some Acne Scarring |
Calcium Hydroxylapatatite (CaHA) Particles Suspended in a Hyaluronic Acid Gel |
Approx. 1 year |
Throughout the facial area |
Restylane® |
Lines in lower face, under eyes, increase lip size |
Hyaluronic Acid |
Lips: 3 to 6 months, Other: 6 to 9 months |
Lips, underneath the eyes, lines such as frown lines and creases |
JUVÉDERM® |
Moderate to Deep wrinkling |
Hyaluronic Acid |
Approx. 1 year |
Lips, Mouth Wrinkles, Facial lines |
Perlane® |
Facial wrinkles, lips, lines and creases on the face |
Hyaluronic Acid |
9 to 12 months |
Lips, fines lines around mouth and eyes, face |